Monday, January 16, 2012

Hostess With The Leastest

Who'll put the wonder in Wonder Bread?

Last week's bankruptcy hammer-blow: Hostess Brands, down for their second count of Chapter 11.

Hostess wobbled on a two-legged stool, supported by Twinkies and Wonder bread. Hostess rode that stool into an era where people don't eat white bread, and they make jokes about Twinkies.

Having said that, we remember that a few years ago TV chef Tony Bourdain brought his Travel Channel show No Reservations to Cleveland. His stops included an old Twinkie factory, abandoned since the 80s. Therein he found an abandoned supply of creamy filling confection. He opened a valve and drank some.

"Twinkie-licious," he said.

There you have it. Twinkies are forever. Hostess...not so much.

The C4:
  1. Relying on signature products as company sustenance is a risky model. Too few organizations have the guts to update their signature products, which means their sustainers are stuck in time.
  2. If you cater to tastes, watch and adjust to how tastes change.
  3. Is bankruptcy still a process of last resort? Why can't some of these guys try harder to right their own ships before bailing on their creditors?
  4. The thirty-first-century archeologists brave enough to bite an ancient Twinkie will find it Twinkie-licious.

Monday, January 9, 2012

Coda for Kodak

The market dun' took my Kodachrome® away-eh.

We're writing too often, these days, of proud old brands that are faltering, fading and failing.

With Kodak, the failure is all the more astonishing because their brand remains synonymous with photography. Indeed, that company is more responsible than any other for putting the tools of picture-taking into the hands of the masses — a goal specifically enumerated by founder George Eastman as early as 1880.

Despite that success, Eastman-Kodak is just days away from Chapter 11 bankruptcy, from the fire-sale liquidation of billions of dollars worth of patents, and from walking away from a mountain of debt, including company bonds and employee pensions.

What killed Kodak? Perhaps they're victims of their own success. Photography is indeed in all our hands now…and in our phones, our computers and all throughout our digital cloud. A company founded on film couldn't seem to manage the shift away from analog. And when they did, belatedly, they were ill-equipped to compete with companies that were digital to their core.

So is this the coda for Kodak? That remains to be seen. They still have the brand that means "camera" to millions. But sadly, it seems as though they have little else.

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Hunting For Goodwill

You are far more valuable than your bottom line.

It's only natural, as we bid farewell to 2011 and ring in '12, to look back, take stock and evaluate a year's worth of performance. Were we lean and competitive? Did we beat expectations? Or was our balance sheet a precarious balancing act?

As we pore over the data, though, let us remember that not all is black and white. Certain aspects of our businesses defy definition, resist categorization and are oh so difficult to put a price on.

We're talking about intangible assets.

These include our intellectual property, our unique trade secrets and the marketing power of our brands. They include also the goodwill of our communities, which is a reward beyond value for our participation, our citizenship and our altruistic leadership.

Is this the kernel of a New Year's resolution? That's for each of us to decide for ourselves. Here at Caler&Company, we aim to embrace the intangible and value to the utmost that which has no price.

Here's to goodwill, good times and a happy and healthy 2012 for all.

Cheers!

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

The End of Longevity?

Why brands without a competitive edge will fail.

Citing poor holiday sales, Sears Holding Corporation this week announced plans to shutter about 115 Sears and Kmart stores nationwide.

Not wishing to pile on to an unfortunate situation, but we can’t help but wonder if we’re seeing a failure of brand here — or more specifically, the failure to keep two venerable brands updated and relevant.

After all, what’s Kmart? A discount store, certainly, but what differentiates it from the world’s largest discount seller? Walmart is not only the world’s largest retailer, they sell more TVs, groceries, toys, guns and diamonds than any other company in the world. What has Kmart done to compete with that? And if they can’t compete, how do they distinguish themselves?

And Sears, founded in 1886, is one of our oldest retailers. Their history is long, storied and honorable. But are they modern? Are they competitive? When was the last time you shopped at Sears?

Longevity is enviable, but it’s nothing without competitiveness and relevancy. Lacking those vital components, longevity can cease at any time.

The C4:
  1. Longevity requires a strong brand.
  2. A strong brand requires differentiation.
  3. Differentiation requires competitiveness.
  4. Competitiveness requires a desire for longevity.

Monday, December 19, 2011

Stand & Deliver

Are you ready to do what it takes?

These days, a company's continuing existence is testament to its adaptability. If you're still standing, that means you've rolled with every technological landslide and demographic shift that recent history has thrown at you.

Which is good, because all that has just been practice for your biggest challenge yet: The fundamental transformation of the American consumer's psyche.

The Great Recession of 2007–2009 left a more pessimistic consumer. One who's holding less debt, less purchasing power and who is far more thoughtful — maybe downright adverse — to all but the most basic purchases.

Consumers will continue to demand the utmost in service and value, while things like brand loyalty will mean less and less. Far fewer dollars will be spent, and there will be economic casualties. There will be winners too, though, consisting of those players willing to beat their competition in giving the consumer what he or she wants.

That's the line we plan on being in. Hope to see you there.

The C4:
  1. If you're still standing, congrats — you're a testament to adaptability.
  2. Now begins the process of changing consumers' mindsets — but it won't be easy.
  3. Consumers' demands are high, but their attitudes are challenging.
  4. Those who want to keep standing will give the consumer what they want.